Harrisburg PA is actually really awesome

IMG_8552

Harrisburg, PA as viewed from City Island

To the extent that Harrisburg has a reputation throughout Pennsylvania, its known as the home of the state’s oversized legislature and intractable politics.  It is known to cross-state travelers as a drive-past, fly-over, sleep-through (Amtrak) city.  To less curious Harrisburg-area residents, its thought of as a crime-filled hell hole they would hardly drive through.  To Donald “Chicken” Trump, Harrisburg is a “war zone.”

But the reality is – as I discovered over the course of many months working, exploring, and dining in Harrisburg – Pennsylvania’s capital and 11th most populous city is, actually, really awesome.

In this non-comprehensive account, I’ll note the city’s architecture and scenic surroundings, its outstanding small-business Third Places, its abundance of locally-sourced humane food eateries, and some of the benefits of life in a small city (albeit, a small city with frequent high-speed rail access and decent economic opportunities).

IMG_8405

Wildwood Lake Park and its spillway

Of course Harrisburg – like virtually every city on earth – is laden with problems.  The most significant and obvious of which are racial segregation and the fact that almost half of the city’s residents are impoverished.  But because these facts are par for American cities, and because they’re hardly inherent features, they shouldn’t be counted against Harrisburg.

How I got to know The Burg

My window into life in Pennsylvania’s capital was opened on two occasions.  The first was weekly commuting to Harrisburg over nine months in 2013-2014 while I was a Pittsburgh resident. (The joys of regular-ism on Amtrak’s Pennsylvanian and the amazing utility of folding bicycles are subjects for another post.)  During this stint I got a feel for the city and became a regular at Home 231 and the Midtown Scholar, and a reader of The Burg (Harrisburg’s “city paper”.)

More recently, a SEPTA colleague and myself stayed in Harrisburg for a two week PennDOT course (NBIS bridge inspection certification).  My current stint is revealing a different angle on the city because I’m (bike) commuting to a different location, and because multiple new and positive developments took place in the past two years (discussed later).

HBG MAP

Terrain and bike trail map of Harrisburg.  Red dots give a sense of my respective commutes.  Capital Greenbelt visible as trail segments encircling “Harrisburg”.  Mountain ridge (and Susquehanna gap) upper left.  Wildwood Lake Park is the lake near “WORK” (Credit Google Maps)

Natural & Architectural Beauty

Harrisburg (and its suburbs) are surrounded by the lush greenery of central Pennsylvania.  The elongated peaks of the Appalachian Mountains are within view of downtown and other vantage points.  (The Appalachian Trail crosses the Susquehanna River near Harrisburg.)

A defining feature of the city’s geography is the wide, shallow Susquehanna River.  Harrisburg’s easy-to-use bridges and stately waterfront architecture are a function of the apparent non-navigability of the Susquehanna as a shipping waterway.

GOOD USE

Iso view of Harrisburg – City Island in middle of river.  Neighborhoods at waterfront, industry to the east.  Reservoir Park in the upper right. (Credit Google Maps)

Although its possible to walk across the river in spots, at least seven bridges cross the Susquehanna close to or within the city.  Ranging from 100+ year old stone arches to 1950’s steel crossings to a modern segmental concrete box girder (the Turnpike), these bridges share similar characteristics (many short spans, and deck elevations on-level with landed roadways, railways, walkways).

The effects of this are: a pleasing visual motif, ease of walking or biking across, and less disruption to neighborhoods (except, of course, for the I-81 and I-83 highway bridges which feature divisive approaches and do not serve people on foot).

IMG_8546

Two concrete arch railroad bridges over the Susquehanna

The industrial disutility of the Susquehanna also made for an attractive waterfront.  Despite the Harrisburg area’s rich industrial past, little of it appears to have occurred on the Susquehanna, as evidenced by vintage architecture and old-growth trees lining Front Street and the riverfront park.  (Industry appears to have been concentrated along the railroad yards behind the historic city, and the remnants of the Pennsylvania Canal, and in Steelton, south of Harrisburg.)

IMG_8575

Riverfront park with double pathway, old trees, historic architecture.

Passing through the linear park – covering nearly five miles of the Susquehanna riverfront – is a well-used recreational pathway.  This is a segment of the Capital Area Greenbelt, a 20-mile loop through and around Harrisburg.  Significant portions of the greenbelt are biking/walking trails.  Other parts use low-traffic neighborhood streets.  (A few areas remain awkward and dangerous.)  Navigating the trail is easy due to abundant directional signage.

IMG_8491

Viewing Amtrak from the Greenbelt

Complimenting Harrisburg’s natural scenery is the city’s rich and diverse historic architecture.  Perhaps because Harrisburg never expanded at the rate of Philadelphia, there’s less repetition among the housing stock.  Varied and interesting homes and buildings, as well as successive eras of city growth can be appreciated by walking on Green Street from downtown (to the wall that is I-81).

There is of course the grand government architecture of the Pennsylvania State Capitol Complex, and the historic and cosmic streetscapes projecting west and east (respectively) from the Capitol building.  (For now, we’ll overlook the significant volume of downtown buildings serving no other purpose than to store motor vehicles.)

 

Amazing Third Places

I’m enamored with the quality of Harrisburg’s eateries, café, coffee shops, bars, and other Third Places (a term coined by Ray Oldenburg in his 1989 book The Great Good Place).

My favorite joint is the Midtown Scholar, an extensive bookstore-café fronting 3rd Street (in the Midtown neighborhood).  Housed in an old timber industrial building, the establishment’s main room serves as a community multi-purpose venue for all kinds of events.  The collection, housed mostly in the basement and spilling out onto the street, includes endless vintage volumes, locally-specific titles, and much else.  Crucially, the Scholar is open until 9 PM weeknights.  (It’s tough to find any café with decent evening hours in Center City Philly or anywhere in Pittsburgh.)  As far as I can tell, neither city contains a Third Place quite like the Midtown Scholar.

IMG_8436

Midtown Scholar fronting 3rd Street

IMG_8401

Midtown Scholar pano view

Then there’s Little Amps Coffee Roasters, a straightforward, thoughtful coffee shop with down-to-earth baristas and delicious coffee.  Spawning out of their original location in the charming Uptown neighborhood, they also occupy the corner of 2nd and State Street near the Capitol.  At Little Amps is where (as an out-of-towner) I was readily clued into local goings on including 3rd In The Burg (monthly Friday art crawls), and good live music at HMAC.

Upon my return to Harrisburg this month, there were new places and things to do, partly because I had a colleague with whom to enjoy the city (and the Greenbelt trail), and because a few very positive developments had taken place.

These happy new components of Harrisburg’s Third Place prowess include Little Amps Coffee Roasters’ new Strawberry Square location, the new Sawyer’s beer garden on 2nd Street downtown, and the massive expansion of Midtown Arts Center (HMAC) music venue into a huge bar with a front porch on 3rd Street.

IMG_8586

New Little Amps shop in downtown’s mall-like Strawberry Square

But most significant is The Millworks in Midtown.  Recommended by multiple people, Millworks is a combination brewery / rooftop bar / locally-sourced restaurant / art gallery and studio.  (They began serving their own beer last Tuesday.)  I don’t know of an equal in Pittsburgh or Philadelphia.

IMG_8433

Rooftop bar at Millworks

Other places I frequented and/or appreciated during my Harrisburg escapades are too many to discuss (but are listed here for effect).

IMG_8304

Pano view of the Senators vs. the Erie SeaWolves

Small City with Big Advantages

From my perspective, having lived in New York, Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, Washington, D.C., Harrisburg would be a great place to live.  Philadelphia and Pittsburgh deservedly get more attention (both being large metropoles) but not everyone who’s interested in city life is enthused about big city life.

What Harrisburg lacks in the way of big city amenities (principally, multiplicity of choice), it makes up for in affordability, access to the outdoors, excellent Third Places, and a depth of public life that is possible only within a small-to-midsize community of people.

IMG_8566

A father and son bike on the riverfront near Market Street Bridge

Indeed, Harrisburg enjoys unique and meaningful advantages over similarly-sized central Pennsylvania cities (like Wilkes-Barre, State College) including the economic and political opportunities relating to State government, and frequent, comfortable, high-speed (by US standards) trains to Philadelphia and New York.  (Within the United States, this level of inter-city rail service is a rarity.)

So – if you’re itching for a local, low-cost getaway in which to explore civics, history, urbanism, and the outdoors; or if you’re in search of a great small city to call home with good opportunities (and easy access to big cities), Harrisburg, Pennsylvania is more than worth a closer look.

25 thoughts on “Harrisburg PA is actually really awesome

  1. Thanks for this writeup, it was really interesting to read. I was only in Harrisburg once, a very long time ago, and I’d like to explore it again. I was impressed that it seemed like an actual place. I feel like non-major-city state capitals are often both regarded and treated as single-use districts with no real life, like Trenton. It’s great to see that Harrisburg is also a real life place. I’d love to take a train trip out there some time and experience it now.

    • Interesting thing about the USA is almost all state capitals are not the biggest cities. Also the US capital isn’t one of the biggest cities. This is distinct from London, Paris, Madrid.

  2. Harrisburg is like Pennsylvania’s answer to Grand Rapids.

    In other words, dont sleep on Big GR.*

    *side note- I am not from nor have I ever lived in GR.

  3. Harrisburg is a great little city but it is missing the arts. The art museum has no significant works of its own. The art culture is lacking and the galleries that do exist are full of amateur work. The music scene is better but is still lacking for a city of this size.

  4. You don’t know anything. Mid town is discussing. Harrisburg, for being such a small city their crime rate is through the roof. And living in the city is costly, it’s more costly than some areas of Pittsburgh.

    • The best thing about Harrisburg is its low cost of living. I’ve lived in Boston, Miami, San Francisco & Santa Monica and Harrisburg is the only city I could afford to buy a home. I live on the river and get spectacular sunsets everyday! It’s incredible!

  5. Great article and good observations!
    Thank you for noting Harrisburg’s Third in the Burg art night which happens the Third Friday of every month. Many wonderful venues filled with high quality, professional art works.
    All readers are encouraged to visit
    “Vivi on Verbeke” during Third in the Burg. – 258 Verbeke Street, between noon and 10 p.m. We are only one block from the Midtown Scholar. The superlative works of seasoned
    photographer and metal worker Jackson Boyd and the master clay works and paintings of the multi-dimensional Vivian Sterste are displayed and sold here. We hope to meet those who have not found us yet soon!

  6. I really like your article, but don’t forget the National Historic Landmark John Harris-Simon Cameron Mansion (c. 1766), home to the city’s founder, trader and ferry operator, John Harris, Jr., and later to Simon Cameron, (1799-1889), Pennsylvania political boss and Lincoln’s first Secretary of War. The Victorian showplace is open for tours and hosts public programming on historical topics. See http://www.dauphincountyhistory.org.

  7. It makes me so sad that the city I love is the same city I cannot afford to be a home owner in. It’s great for professional workers. But, as a low paid working class worker I simply can’t afford the property taxes even though I have no children and simply aspired to own a modest single family town house. I had to buy outside of the city limit to be a home owner.

    • Thank you for sharing this – but it confuses me a little bit, because I observed that many of Harrisburg neighborhoods are home to low-income residents. Perhaps only a few are home owners. Furthermore, at what point does reduced dependence on a car produce enough savings to afford owning a home in the city?

  8. Bring your weapons to defend yourself.. 11 murders in 8 months. Don’t go near uptown, the hill, downtown .. Dangerous ! See the slums & ghetto everywhere. TAX money used to rebuild multi-family dwellings & they destroy them in a few years because they don’t take pride in anything that’s given to them at no cost. Most suburbanites work hard for a living, take pride in their surroundings & don’t break the laws. Middletown is the same.

  9. I lived there for ten years and enjoyed bike commuting to the capitol from the West Shore for one year and from Shipoke (lower end of the city next to the river in a cute three story house). Memories include actually seeing both Pavarotti and Yitsak Pearlman perform at the education building called The Forum. Pavarotti came out onto the stage when the arena was empty–he was astonished by the beautiful venue–“This is Fabulous” he said–so amazed at the contellations in the ceiling and small size, like an Italian opera house. So glad to hear Harrisburg is looking beautiful. It is a special city on the river.

  10. I live in the historic midtown district of Harrisburg and I love it. My husband and I have lived here since 1997 and are raising a daughter who is 15. It’s not perfect but it’s good. Thanks for kind words about a place I love.

  11. So nice to see positive comments about a great city and a fabulous area. Centeral Pennsylvania is a great place to be and call home.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s